Concept · CGEL §12.3.5.4.4
That which and all who: obligatory wh
When the antecedent is 'that which' or 'all who', a wh-relative clause is obligatorily used.
What it is
Certain fixed expressions or constructions strongly prefer or require a specific type of relative clause. For the antecedent 'that which', meaning 'what', the relative clause must be a wh-relative. Similarly, when 'all' refers to people and functions as the antecedent for a relative clause, the wh-word 'who' (or 'whom') is obligatory. Using 'that' or a bare relative in these specific contexts would typically sound ungrammatical or highly awkward. This demonstrates how the choice of relative clause type can be lexically or structurally constrained.
Examples
He understood that which was explained.
Clause ├── Subj:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro He └── Head:VP ├── Head:V understood └── Obj:NP ├── Det-Head:DP ─ Head:D that └── Mod:Clause_rel ├── Prenucleus:NP {x} ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro which └── Head:Clause_rel ─ Head:VP ├── Head:V_aux was └── Comp:Clause ─ Head:VP ├── Head:V explained └── Subj:GAP {x} ___
Bracketed form
Clause[ Subj:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"He" ] ], Head:VP[ Head:V"understood", Obj:NP[ Det-Head:DP[ Head:D"that" ], Mod:Clause_rel[ Prenucleus:NP{index=x}[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"which" ] ], Head:Clause_rel[ Head:VP[ Head:V_aux"was", Comp:Clause[ Head:VP[ Head:V"explained", Subj:GAP{index=x} ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ]All who attended received a gift.
Clause ├── Subj:NP │ ├── Det-Head:DP ─ Head:D all │ └── Mod:Clause_rel │ ├── Prenucleus:NP {x} ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro who │ └── Head:Clause_rel ─ Head:VP │ ├── Head:V attended │ └── Subj:GAP {x} ___ └── Head:VP ├── Head:V received └── Obj:NP ├── Det:DP ─ Head:D a └── Head:Nom ─ Head:N gift
Bracketed form
Clause[ Subj:NP[ Det-Head:DP[ Head:D"all" ], Mod:Clause_rel[ Prenucleus:NP{index=x}[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"who" ] ], Head:Clause_rel[ Head:VP[ Head:V"attended", Subj:GAP{index=x} ] ] ] ], Head:VP[ Head:V"received", Obj:NP[ Det:DP[ Head:D"a" ], Head:Nom[ Head:N"gift" ] ] ] ]Formalism
Formal statement
If the antecedent is NP[ Det-Head:DP[ Head:D"that" ] ] or NP[ Det-Head:DP[ Head:D"all" ] ], the modifying Clause_rel must be a wh-relative (Prenucleus:NP[WH=+]).
Builds on
In CGEL
§12.3.5.4.4 That which and all who: obligatory wh ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/9e86fc2c-af6c-46de-9ad0-20b655fc4416
Readable alias /concept/that-which-and-all-who-obligatory-wh