Concept · CGEL §10.6.4
Rejection of Q–A presuppositions
Rejection of a Q-A presupposition occurs when a listener challenges the underlying assumption of a question.
What it is
Rejection of a Q-A presupposition happens when a listener responds to a question by directly denying the assumption that the question makes. Instead of answering the question directly, the listener points out that the premise of the question is false. For example, if asked 'Who stole the cookies?', a rejection might be 'Nobody stole them; they were given away.' This response doesn't provide the identity of a thief but rather negates the presupposition that a theft occurred, thus challenging the validity of the question itself.
Example
Speaker A: 'When did you stop playing the piano?' Speaker B: 'I never started playing the piano.'
Formalism
Not yet formalised.
In CGEL
§10.6.4 Rejection of Q–A presuppositions ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/771e0bde-c486-4d86-92a7-ab76d16a1915
Readable alias /concept/rejection-of-q-a-presuppositions