Concept · CGEL §10.7.6.1
Presupposition cancellation
Presupposition cancellation occurs when 'why' challenges the truth of the proposition it questions.
What it is
Normally, a 'why' question presupposes that the event or state being questioned is true. For example, 'Why did you break the vase?' implies the vase was indeed broken. However, 'why' can also be used to challenge this presupposition, effectively denying the truth of the proposition. This is known as presupposition cancellation. In such cases, the speaker is not asking for a reason but rather questioning the very occurrence of the event, often with skepticism or disbelief. It functions as a rhetorical device to express doubt.
Example
Why did you say I was late?
Formalism
Not yet formalised.
In CGEL
§10.7.6.1 Presupposition cancellation ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/20c1aee9-3ed5-41ed-8721-66a308a4fcaa
Readable alias /concept/presupposition-cancellation