gCanonical English Grammar

Concept · CGEL §7.4.3

PPs of the form spoonful by spoonful

Certain iterative or distributive PPs, like 'spoonful by spoonful,' have a fixed structure and cannot be easily modified or reordered.

What it is

These PPs express a repetitive or gradual action, often with a noun repeated on either side of a preposition, such as 'day by day' or 'step by step.' Their structure is highly idiomatic and rigid, meaning the individual components cannot be easily separated, modified, or reordered without losing their specific meaning or becoming ungrammatical. For instance, you cannot typically insert adjectives between the noun and preposition, nor can you easily extract one part of the phrase while leaving the other. They function as a single unit, often adverbially, describing how an action unfolds.

Example

She ate the soup spoonful by spoonful.

Formalism

Formal statement

A PP of the form N[Head:N] P[Head:P] NP[Head:Nom[Head:N]] functions as a fixed idiomatic unit, often as a Mod:PP.

In CGEL

§7.4.3 PPs of the form spoonful by spoonful ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.

Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/876c217e-e33c-4356-9308-5006b1801a43
Readable alias /concept/pps-of-the-form-spoonful-by-spoonful