Concept · CGEL §15.3.4.3
Mixed coordinations
Mixed coordinations involve combining different types of genitive expressions, which often leads to ungrammaticality.
What it is
Mixed coordinations refer to attempts to combine different forms of genitive expressions within a single coordinated phrase. For example, trying to coordinate a regular noun phrase with an 's genitive (e.g., 'the boy's') and a genitive pronoun (e.g., 'mine') is generally ungrammatical if the genitive marker is meant to apply to the whole. This is because genitive pronouns already carry the possessive meaning and cannot take an additional 's marker, nor do they easily integrate into a structure where 's is applied to the entire coordination. Such constructions usually require restructuring into separate, parallel genitive phrases.
Examples
*The student and my's project was successful.
The student's project and my project were successful.
Formalism
Formal statement
A Coordination node cannot contain Coordinate:NP constituents of fundamentally different genitive types (e.g., a genitive N"'s" NP and a genitive D"my" NP) if the genitive property is intended to be shared across the coordination.
Builds on
In CGEL
§15.3.4.3 Mixed coordinations ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/b06a54f6-c8ff-4b97-aeab-417d5b504e46
Readable alias /concept/mixed-coordinations