gCanonical English Grammar

Concept · CGEL §11.5.3.2.2.1

Marginal status of closed interrogatives in contexts of weak answer-orientation

Closed interrogatives are less natural in contexts of weak answer-orientation, though not strictly ungrammatical.

What it is

In contexts where the answer-orientation is present but not extremely strong, closed interrogatives (yes/no questions) may sound marginal or slightly awkward, rather than completely ungrammatical. For example, verbs like 'discover' or 'find out' lean towards answer-orientation, as they imply gaining knowledge. While "I discovered whether she left" might be understood, it is less natural than "I discovered that she left" or "I discovered who left." This indicates a preference for open interrogatives or declarative clauses when the focus is on the content of the answer rather than the question itself.

Examples

I discovered whether he had finished.

Clause
├── Subj:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro  I
└── Head:VP
    ├── Head:V  discovered
    └── Obj:Clause
        ├── Marker:Sdr  whether
        └── Head:Clause
            ├── Subj:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro  he
            └── Head:VP
                ├── Head:V_aux  had
                └── Comp:Clause ─ Head:VP ─ Head:V  finished
Bracketed form
Clause[ Subj:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"I" ] ], Head:VP[ Head:V"discovered", Obj:Clause[ Marker:Sdr"whether", Head:Clause[ Subj:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"he" ] ], Head:VP[ Head:V_aux"had", Comp:Clause[ Head:VP[ Head:V"finished" ] ] ] ] ] ] ]

I discovered who had finished.

Clause
├── Subj:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro  I
└── Head:VP
    ├── Head:V  discovered
    └── Obj:Clause
        ├── Prenucleus:NP {x} ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro  who
        └── Head:Clause ─ Head:VP
            ├── Head:V_aux  had
            └── Comp:Clause ─ Head:VP
                ├── Head:V  finished
                └── Subj:GAP {x}  ___
Bracketed form
Clause[ Subj:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"I" ] ], Head:VP[ Head:V"discovered", Obj:Clause[ Prenucleus:NP{index=x}[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"who" ] ], Head:Clause[ Head:VP[ Head:V_aux"had", Comp:Clause[ Head:VP[ Head:V"finished", Subj:GAP{index=x} ] ] ] ] ] ] ]

Formalism

Not yet formalised.

In CGEL

§11.5.3.2.2.1 Marginal status of closed interrogatives in contexts of weak answer-orientation ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.

Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/9943ac21-f88b-475c-bf23-7a179e66e5c5
Readable alias /concept/marginal-status-of-closed-interrogatives-in-contexts-of-weak-answer-orientation