Concept · CGEL §15.2.2.1.4
Exclusiveness as an implicature of or
The exclusive meaning of 'or' is often an implication, not an inherent logical property, and can be cancelled.
What it is
When we use 'or', we often imply that only one of the options is true, but not both. For example, 'You can have coffee or tea' usually means you choose one, not both. However, this 'exclusiveness' is a conversational implicature, meaning it's an inference the listener makes, rather than a strict logical rule. This is important because, unlike a logical truth, an implicature can be explicitly cancelled or overridden without creating a contradiction, demonstrating its non-essential nature.
Example
You can have soup or salad, and maybe both.
Clause ├── Subj:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N_pro you └── Head:VP ├── Head:V_aux can └── Comp:Clause ─ Head:VP ├── Head:V have ├── Obj:Coordination │ ├── Coordinate:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N soup │ ├── Marker:Coordinator or │ └── Coordinate:NP ─ Head:Nom ─ Head:N salad └── Mod:Coordination ├── Marker:Coordinator and ├── Coordinate:AdvP ─ Head:Adv maybe └── Coordinate:NP ─ Det-Head:DP ─ Head:D both
Bracketed form
Clause[ Subj:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N_pro"you" ] ], Head:VP[ Head:V_aux"can", Comp:Clause[ Head:VP[ Head:V"have", Obj:Coordination[ Coordinate:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N"soup" ] ], Marker:Coordinator"or", Coordinate:NP[ Head:Nom[ Head:N"salad" ] ] ], Mod:Coordination[ Marker:Coordinator"and", Coordinate:AdvP[ Head:Adv"maybe" ], Coordinate:NP[ Det-Head:DP[ Head:D"both" ] ] ] ] ] ] ]
Formalism
Formal statement
The interpretation of 'X or Y' where both X and Y are true is often pragmatically disfavored but not logically excluded.
In CGEL
§15.2.2.1.4 Exclusiveness as an implicature of or ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/6d44624e-17f6-4cf0-bbc1-821887bc099f
Readable alias /concept/exclusiveness-as-an-implicature-of-or