Concept · CGEL §1.2.2
Disagreement between descriptivist and prescriptivist work
Descriptive and prescriptive grammars often disagree on what constitutes 'correct' or 'grammatical' language.
What it is
The fundamental difference in goals between descriptive and prescriptive approaches inevitably leads to disagreements regarding specific linguistic forms. Prescriptivists, guided by rules often rooted in historical precedent or social convention, may label common usages as 'incorrect' or 'ungrammatical'. Descriptivists, observing actual language use, will instead analyze these forms as part of the living language system, seeking to explain their structure and function within the community that uses them. These disagreements highlight the tension between codified rules and evolving linguistic reality, often leading to debates about what constitutes legitimate English.
Example
A descriptivist accepts "who are you talking to?", while a prescriptivist might insist on "to whom are you talking?".
Formalism
Not yet formalised.
In CGEL
§1.2.2 Disagreement between descriptivist and prescriptivist work ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/809f347b-a5e6-48e0-90e5-20b846155f1b
Readable alias /concept/disagreement-between-descriptivist-and-prescriptivist-work