Concept · CGEL §7.4.1.5.5
The PP is in adjunct function
Preposition stranding is generally disallowed when the prepositional phrase functions as an adjunct.
What it is
Preposition stranding occurs when a preposition's complement is moved, leaving the preposition 'stranded'. This is typically permitted when the prepositional phrase (PP) functions as a complement to a verb or adjective, as in 'Who are you waiting for?'. However, if the PP acts as an adjunct, providing additional, optional information about time, place, or manner, stranding is usually ungrammatical. Adjuncts are less tightly integrated into the clause structure, making extraction from them more difficult. For instance, 'Which day did you arrive on?' is acceptable, but 'Which city did you meet them in?' is less natural if 'in which city' is purely an adjunct.
Example
*Which city did you meet them in?
Formalism
Formal statement
If PP is Mod:PP, then PP[ Head:P, Obj:GAP{index=x} ] is generally ill-formed.
Builds on
In CGEL
§7.4.1.5.5 The PP is in adjunct function ↗
Gated reader; sign-in required.
Permanent link https://grammar.canonical-english.org/c/72baae73-cb22-4077-b9b4-f4ccf0185f57
Readable alias /concept/the-pp-is-in-adjunct-function